Prevention of Dog Mauling in SF: Develop the Human-Dog Bond

The Human-Dog bond is ancient, dating back centuries in many cultures around the world. A bond is developed between human and dog through professional dog obedience training of the HUMAN and the dog, through proper socialization of the dog with other dogs and humans and through responsible dog ownership which includes meeting all of the rights a dog has in living in proximity with a human family, such as listed below:
Pet's Bill of Rights
Anonymous

We have the right to be full members of your family. We thrive on social interaction, praise, and love.

We have the right to stimulation. We need new games, new toys, new experiences, and new smells to be happy.

We have the right to regular exercise. Without it, we could become hyper, sluggish...or fat.

We have the right to have fun. We enjoy acting like clowns now and then; don't expect us to be predictable all the time.

We have the right to quality health care. Please stay good friends with our vet.

We have the right to a good diet. Like some people, we don't know what's best for us. We depend on you.

We have the right not to be rejected because of your expectations that we be great show dogs or show cats, watchdogs, hunters, or baby-sitters.

We have the right to receive proper training. Otherwise, our good relationship could be marred by confusion and strife - and we could become dangerous to ourselves and others.

We have the right to guidance and correction based on understanding and compassion, rather than abuse.

We have the right to live with dignity...and to die with dignity when the time comes.
******************************************************************
Responible dog ownership also includes responsible management of children/dog interaction, as outlined below:

Children & Dogs

Children and dogs are a natural, but because of a child's small size and unpredictable behavior there are several things every pet owner or parent should know about children and dogs. This article will help parents decide which dog is best for small children, as well as how to introduce a new dog to a family with children. The article will also discuss special health risks and common behavior problems, which can occur between dogs and children.
As a veterinarian and a parent of two small boys that share our home with a dog and two cats, I deal with the issues of children and pets on a regular basis. Children and dogs can be the best of friends if you follow a few of these simple guidelines and precautions.

Choosing the right dog at the right time

Not every dog is right for children and not every child is right for a dog. The vast majority of dog/child problems I encounter involve children under six years of age. If your children are under six you should invest a great deal of time and thought before choosing a new dog. Large dogs that have been bred as guard dogs or have a history of being aggressive or biting should be avoided. Large, high-energy dogs that can knock children over or dogs that bark excessively would not be good choices, as well.

Parents with small children are usually very busy; they often do not have the free time or desire to spend hours grooming or walking a high maintenance dog. Initially, puppies require almost as much time as a child does, so ask yourself if you are ready to bring a new puppy into a home that is already too busy. As a veterinarian, many of the problems I encounter occur because a dog was purchased because the dog would be 'good for the kids' or the children begged for one, but the parent did not really want a dog. If the parents are not one hundred percent committed to caring for and training the dog, then I usually discourage them from acquiring a dog, otherwise it is not fair to the people or the dog.

By the time children are seven or older some of them are ready to start to develop a rewarding relationship with a dog. If you want to see true happiness just look at the face of an 8-year-old when they hold their new lab puppy in their arms for the first time. Dogs can help teach a child responsibility, patience, empathy, and compassion, but remember, no young child is capable of properly training or completely caring for a dog, so the parent must always ultimately take full responsibility for the pet.

Bringing a dog into a family with children

After you have decided that a new dog or puppy is right for your family and have one picked out, take some time to get your house puppy-proofed and acquire the necessary puppy items before bringing your puppy home.

When you bring the puppy home make sure it has several days to adjust before it is played with too much. Make up a set of house rules for the children concerning the new dog and post it on the refrigerator. Decide where the dog will sleep. I personally recommend that a dog sleeps on his own bed and not in the bed with children, as I have dealt with numerous behavioral and medical problems resulting from this practice.

Remember that your children will have to be trained on how to treat the dog, so plan on spending lots of time training the dog and the children. This pet will be with you for a long time so spend the time now to avoid unwanted behavior in the future. Educate yourself. Buy and read training books and consider enrolling your puppy in an obedience class. Well-trained dogs are a joy to be around and are a requirement if children are involved.

Bringing a new child into a family with pets

A common worry of new parents is how their dog will react when they bring a new baby into the house. Many parents often worry about potential health risks for their children, which we will discuss later in this article. Most dogs do fine when a baby is brought into the house. They are going to be curious and may feel neglected, but these feelings will soon pass. If the parents will take extra time out of each day both before and after the baby is born to play with, exercise, and groom the dog, the transition should go smoothly.

A newborn baby interacts very little with a dog, so most problems in the household start when the baby turns into a toddler and starts invading the dog's space. A toddler is not able to understand rules and should not be expected to 'leave the dog alone.' This is the time when the dog will be happier if he has his own space. Our dog spends a lot more of her time outside now that our children are both over two years old, and will probably do so until the youngest is at least four. Everyone, including the dog, is happier with this arrangement. Remember that when the baby comes home everyone will have less free time, except the dog. So make extra time for the dog and he should be fine.

The relationship between dogs and children

Dogs have a unique relationship with people. As the understanding of the 'pack' mentality becomes more prevalent, it becomes easier to see why dogs act the way they do. Understanding and altering dog behavior revolves around understanding dog behavior and the importance of dominance and submission in the dog psyche. It is important to remember that in the dog's mind the family is a pack unit and everyone in that family has a certain 'position' in the pack. In most families, one or both of the parents are considered the pack leaders and the dog is subordinate to them. Now depending on the dog, this may be very obvious or it may not really matter much. But when small children are involved, it has been my experience that dogs almost always consider the children equal or lower in the pack hierarchy than they are, and this is where the problem arises.

Because the dog considers the child a subordinate, it may refuse to obey the child's commands or 'accidentally' bump into the child and knock her down. It may escalate to growling at the child when the child is near food or toys, or even baring his teeth and biting when the child approaches or tries to play with the dog. It is essential that the parent understands this hierarchal relationship and takes precautions to prevent problems from arising. Such behaviors are an indication that professional help, such as your veterinarian or an animal behaviorist, are needed.

Why dogs bite children, and how to prevent it

When dogs bite adults it is usually out of fear and perhaps out of aggression. When dogs bite children it may also be from fear or aggression, but I feel that many times it is what I call 'warning bite.' The warning bite is usually to the face or hand and while traumatic for the child, is often not serious in a medical nature.

While I consider any dog bite extremely serious it is important to distinguish between the nature of the bite to prevent problems in the future. When a dominant dog is unhappy with a subordinate dog he will use a series of body positions to signal that he is unhappy and the subordinate dog better stop what he is doing. If the subordinate dog still does not stop, then the dominant dog will growl and possibly bare his teeth. If the subordinate dog still refuses to obey, the dominant dog will snarl and quickly bite the subordinate dog. The bite is not intended to injure the subordinate dog, but is meant as a stern warning and punishment. This is very similar to what happens to children when they are bitten.

Unfortunately, children are nott able to interpret the dog's language, nor is the dog capable of communicating in any other way. Therefore, almost all dog bites are a result of failure on the parents' part to recognize and prevent potential problem situations. This does not, however, completely take the blame away from the dog. Dogs are capable of learning to control their behavior and not bite, and older children can learn to 'leave the dog alone.' However, when a dog bite occurs, the blame should rest with the adults for failing to prevent it and the child and dog should not be punished for acting like children or dogs.

If a child is bitten and the skin is broken, the wound should be thoroughly cleaned and medical attention should be sought, if necessary. If there is any question as to the rabies vaccination status of the dog, contact the local county nurse for direction. The psychological effects of a dog bite are often much worse than the physical effects. If a child is afraid of dogs after the incident you need to address that problem as well. Slowly introducing the child back to dogs while the child is in a secure environment (being held) is one approach. However, do not underestimate the potential for the child to develop a long-term fear; seek professional help if your child is having trouble adjusting to being around dogs again.

Health concerns for parents of children with dogs

Dogs and people live happily together with a very small risk of infections being transmitted back and forth. However, there are a few special considerations with children. Obviously rabies and dog bites are concerns, and it goes without saying, that all dogs should be vaccinated for rabies, especially dogs that are around children. If you have a dog that does not have a valid rabies certificate of vaccination and it bites a child, be prepared for the very expensive health and legal consequences that will ensue. Your dog should also be current on all recommended vaccines. Children can contract roundworms or hookworms from dog feces, so make sure your puppy and adult dog are de-wormed on a regular basis.

Fleas and ticks can travel from dogs to children, so make sure your dog is protected with a flea and tick preventative. The once-a-month topicals offer excellent protection and are safe if used according to directions. On my own dog, I apply a monthly topical agent at night, after the kids are in bed. I put ten to twelve small 'stripes' down my dog's back to speed absorption, and I try not to let the kids play with the dog the next day. Of course it is a good idea to always have your children wash their hands after playing with the dog.

Allergies affect many children, so keeping the dog out of the childrens sleeping area is always a good idea if your child is prone to allergies.

As a final note in the health section, I want to remind parents that I personally recommend that a dog and small child are never left alone unattended. Even the oldest, sweetest most passive dog and the best-behaved child cannot completely be trusted alone. I have witnessed first hand many instances where a loving child or dog was injured when left unsupervised.

Simple solutions for common dog children problems

The following is a list of some common dog child problems that arise and a list of possible solutions. For a more detailed list of behavior problems and their solutions see our Behavior and Training section.

The dog barks and wakes up the sleeping child or baby.

Solutions: Use a bark training aid or an electronic anti-barking collar.
Move the dog outside or to the basement when the baby is sleeping.
Let the dog bark and the baby will get used to it and sleep through it.

The dog runs into the child by 'accident' and knocks them down.

Solutions: Recognize when the behavior usually happens (when the dog is excited about going for a walk) and have the dog go into a down and stay position.
Put the dog outside when the children are practicing their walking.
Teach the child to tell the dog to sit when the dog is getting too excited.


The dog steals the child's food or begs at the table.

Solutions: Move the dog out of the kitchen during mealtime.
Have a bag of special treats that are just for the dog and discourage feeding table food.
Work on obedience training.

The dog jumps up on children.

Solutions: Never allow jumping on anyone for any reason, ever.
Teach the child to raise their knee and turn their hip toward the dog when they jump.
Initiate puppy training at a very young age to prevent this behavior.

The dog growls or snaps at the children.

Solutions: Develop a zero tolerance for dog aggression and institute strict obedience training for the dog.
Counsel the child on their behavior.
Eliminate the source of conflict; move the food bowl, remove the toy, install a doggie door so the dog has a place where he can sleep or be left alone.

The child comes in contact with dog feces.

Solutions: Accompany the dog outside and clean up after him immediately.
Have the dog's toilet area in a different place than the play area.
Pay the child 25 cents as a reward for each 'pile' they report for clean up.

There is no greater relationship than that between a child and their dog. Follow some good common sense precautions and choose the right dog at the right time for your child. A child and a dog both require a huge investment of your time. If you devote the time to both, your rewards will be far greater than anything money could ever buy.
***********************************************************

In calling for the formation of a WORKING COMMITTEE on preventing dog maulings, Mayor Newsom has stated:

There are a number of options that cities across the country have implemented and I expect that these best practices will be examined and analyzed, said the Mayor. We are going to see what measures if any we should be taking as a city to prevent another senseless death from a dog attack.

Other cities have banned specific breeds, such as the pit bull, and other cities, such as Denver, have codified ordinances providing for the euthanasia of pit bulls, regardless of whether the temperament of any particular pit bull warrants death. Specific breed legislation is NEVER a "best practice" to solve a safety issue because it is contradictory to the basic concepts of professional dog obedience, i.e. EACH DOG IS AN INDIVIDUAL whether purebred or a mixed breed. A punitive practice, (such as the one proposed by the Mayor which mandates the muzzling and leashing of all pit bulls in public for the rest of their lives), applied to all dogs of a particular breed is counter-productive and DANGEROUS because unnecessary restraint will create behavior problems where NONE EXISTED BEFORE since all dogs need to exercise, pant, and drink water freely to maintain good physical and mental health.

In addition to the futility of breed specific legislation, the Mayor is ignoring the fact that many dogs are pit bull mixes, and many dogs that appear to have pit bull physical features are not pit bulls at all, or have very little pit bull genes that are far back in their ancestry. Any codification of breed specific legislation will be vague and unclear and unconstitutional on those counts.

TO PREVENT DOG MAULING ATTACKS IN THE FUTURE, THE CITY OF SAN FRANCISCO MUST CODIFY THE FOLLOWING MEASURES:

1-BAN BREEDING OF ALL BREEDS OF DOGS, unless the AKC guidelines for ethical, conscientious breeding (www.akc.org) are enacted as law and all breeders must register with the city and/or state for licensure.

2-ALL INTACT (reproductive systems) DOGS ARE ILLEGAL, codifying steep financial penalties for non-compliance plus possible impoundment of the dog by SF ACC.

3-SF ACC must fund a low-cost spay/neuter clinic open to all residents of the city, also including vaccination, grooming, microchipping clinics within the scope of services.

4-SF ACC must fund low-cost obedience training for all dogs and develop a panel of professional dog obedience trainers whose expertise covers from puppy socialization to advanced off leash training of the guardian and dog. Suggested trainers are www.doggonegood.org(court-certified), www.johnvanolden.com, and www.courtneygunter.com

5-OBEDIENCE TRAINING of the guardian family and dog(s) must be MANDATORY with penalties that include volunteer hours in SF ACC where the guardian(s)will be exposed to concepts of the human-dog bond.

6-SF ACC will develop an EDUCATIONAL, OUTREACH PROGRAM that includes dog safety presented in schools, on TV media, print media to disseminate and teach the principles of the Human-Dog Bond, Responsible Dog Guardianship, and Managing Child-Dog Interaction and will call upon the greater community of responsible, dog-knowledgeable people to implement the program and work with existing ACC behaviorists and trainers so that a repertoire of obedience methods and philosophies can be selected on an individual dog-by-dog basis.

7-DEPT OF RECREATION AND PARKS will establish a network of parks specifically for dogs in the city so each of the many neighborhoods are served and do not compete with the recreational needs of toddlers and young children.

8-SF ACC will execute and administer a Canine Good Citizen certificate that when presented to potential property owner will guarantee the prospective tenant and their dog(s) rental housing. If more property owners allowed tenants to have dog family members, the euthanasia rate of dogs (and cats) in SF ACC would decrease dramatically. (see www.hsus.org)

San Francisco has a history of being a dog and cat friendly city. It requires the committment of the municipal agencies to continue that legacy which has been modeled across the country to build no-kill animal control facilities. Breed specific legislation and continued backyard, unconscionable breeding will destroy the no-kill legacy that makes many dog and cat guardians proud to be San Franciscans.