Earthsea "miniseries"
Whereas Ged is not another name for Harry Potter, nor for Luke Skywalker.Whereas Ged is quick-tempered and overly proud, but not whiny.Whereas, Vetch's other name is not Samwise Gamgee.Whereas the wiz... continue reading »
"As I sat and tried to make sense of this MESS of a film, all I could do was shake my head in complete disbelief. Not one similairity to the source material. They've THOROUGHLY ruined this wonderful series and probably destroyed any chance of this being tu"
"I support this petition"
"I was so sickened by the five minutes of this miniseries I forced myself to watch that I had to leave the room. These books are classics, jems, and an incredible achievement by their author, LeGuin. Not only was this "film" nothing like the stories, it wa"
"Only the first part of the mini series vagely resembled the story. I am very disapointed too much was changed and a very well writen story was destroyed!!!"
"It belonged on the WB"
"I support this petition"
"After what they did to Battlestar Galactica, my hatred for the Sci Fi Channel is complete. StarCHICK? H*ll no!!"
"If that weren't bad enough - you had to put that scum bag Danny Glover in it !!!!"
"A complete disrgard for the audience and Le Guin's hard work."
"Sci-Fi Channel has no regard for its core audience and I would like to see HBO add new category to its lineup: HBO-SciFi; all those Emmys can't be wrong."
"I support this petition"
"I support this petition"
"This abomination was a disgrace to the books and deserved to be sued as "slanderous libel""
"The key to making a good adaption of any book is to keep the main themes of the story intact, even if the plot has to be changed. The "Earthsea" miniseries neither kept the themes nor plot intact. That's why it was so horrible."
"Dear Ursule-fuking-LeGUIN AND SCI FI chaNNEL STOP RIPPING OFF MY GOD DAMM MOVIES K THX!!~"
"Outrageous and sad. Terribly sad..."
"I support this petition"
"Quite excellently said."
"Honestly, you people call yourselves the SciFi Channel? You should be ashamed of yourselves; anyone who actually cared about science fiction or fantasy wouldn't mangle it like this. There is enough cliched, poorly written fantasy out there already; there "
"I support this petition"
"I support this petition"
"I support this petition"
"I support this petition"
"I support this petition"
"I was appalled at the veritable rape of the literary work of Ursula K. Le Guin. Director Lieberman's about "what Ms. Le Guin intended" shows the contempt exhibited in this farce of a mini series. Another "reimagining" from SciFi? Unfortunately, it seems "
